An Aristocratic Jewish Priest
Sometime in the winter of the year AD 37/38, a baby boy was born to an aristocratic Jewish family in Jerusalem. His father was a priest named Mattityahu in Aramaic (Matthew in English). His mother was the descendent of the kings who ruled 200 years earlier, the famous Maccabees.
This boy was named Yoseph, and he was the second son of the family. His older brother was named Mattityahu after their father.
Yoseph was said to be a child prodigy (at least he later claimed he was) and it’s probably true that he was a genius.
His family were probably Sadducees, the small sect of Jewish aristocrats who ran the Temple and Jerusalem. Yoseph never said this directly, but it seems likely. The family was rich. The men of the family were priests. A close family friend was Yeshua ben Gamaliel, a high priest who was a Sadducee.
Most of our historical sources consider the Sadducees the bad guys. If you like binary thinking, that’s probably accurate. Personally, I like a little more nuance than that, but it’s a good first approximation. The Sadducees were oligarchs who enriched themselves at the expense of everyone else. They collaborated with the Romans to keep the peace, doing the dirty work.
The White Sheep of the Family
It was Sadducees who put Jesus of Nazareth on trial and handed him over to the Roman governor Pilate, calling him a law-breaker in need of a cross. Pilate was a thug who was happy to execute another insurrectionist.
But our lad Yoseph somehow got it into his head as a teenager that he should compare options. He could remain a Sadducee like his father and grandfather before him. He could join the Pharisees, who were keen to update Torah to keep it relevant to modern life in the first-century. Or he could go live the monastic life in the desert with the Essenes.
Yoseph gave all three of these a shot, and he also spent some time with a weirdo guru named Bannus. We know very little about Bannus, but we know plenty about the Essenes and the Pharisees.
In the end, around the age of 19 or 20, Yoseph joined up with the Pharisees. As compared to the Sadducees, these were the good guys, but let’s not forget that some nuance is needed here too. Some of the greatest and holiest men of the first century were Pharisees, and Yoseph studied with them. He became the white sheep of his family. His father and brother must have been very ashamed.
World Traveler
When Yoseph was coming up on the age of 26, he took a voyage to Rome. This must have been about the year AD 63 or 64. His goal was to get some of his friends out of prison in Rome—a fairly ambitious goal. On the way, his ship sank and he had to swim for his life. He befriended an actor, who happened to know the wife of the emperor, Nero.
When they got to Rome, this actor connected Yoseph to the empress, who was interested in exotic eastern religions like the strange religion of the Jews. She helped Yoseph get his friends out of jail.
Yoseph must have been in Rome during the Great Fire of AD 64. Rumors were spreading that Nero started the fire himself to make room for a new palace. Nero had his men spread other rumors that the fire was started by the members of an exotic eastern religion—the so-called Khristianoi, who revered a dead man they claimed had come back to life.
There is no doubt that Yoseph knew about these people, because some of them lived in Jerusalem, and several of their leaders had been recently executed, including a brother of the dead man the Khristianoi revered. Jerusalem was a small town of about 30,000 people, and Yoseph certainly knew about this execution.
While in Rome, Yoseph had plenty of opportunity to see how the Roman military worked. It was the most advanced military in the world, and Yoseph probably studied it carefully. He may well have had a good reason to do so.
Insurrectionist
Yoseph claims that when he returned to Jerusalem, the city was on the brink of revolution. We don’t know exactly when he came home, but a good guess would be the year AD 65.
A year later, in the spring of AD 66, the Roman governor Gessius Florus raided the Temple and stole 17 talents of silver. That works out to about 19,000 troy ounces of silver, which at today’s prices would be nearly a million dollars.
The Judeans living in Jerusalem were enraged, and one thing led to another. By early summer, Jerusalem had revolted against Rome. By fall, the Romans sent a large army of about 30,000 men to put down the revolt—and got their heads handed to them. The Judeans killed an entire legion and sent the rest of the Roman army running for the coast.
And what role did Yoseph play in this revolt? He doesn’t say, other than to claim that he played along with the revolutionaries, for fear of his life. But he takes no credit for any of the fighting up to this point. We have to take this claim with a gigantic grain of salt, because of what happened next.
General of Galilee
The victorious Judeans now prepared for the Empire to strike back. They appointed generals to organize armies in the south, in the east, and in the north. Of these, the army in the north was the most important, because it was obvious the Romans would attack there first, in the region known as Galilee.
Our man Yoseph was appointed the general of the army in Galilee. He claims that he was not keen on this appointment, but played along, again for fear of his life. But he also claims that he raised an army of about 100,000 and fortified all the important towns and cities of Galilee. Again we need a big grain of salt for these claims.
The truth is somewhere in the middle. When the Romans laid siege to a mountain village named Yodefat, Yoseph took charge of the defense. He says he and his men held out there for nearly 7 weeks against a vastly superior force. And this seems close to the truth.
In the end, the Roman army captured the village and caught Yoseph. If everything had gone as normal, he’d have been executed on the spot. But Yoseph was a clever guy, as he tells us many times…
Reluctant Prophet
Yoseph took one look at the conquering general, the Roman senator Vespasian, and told him that he, Yoseph, had been sent by God to announce that he, Vespasian, would someday rule as emperor.
Vespasian was no sucker, but he decided to keep Yoseph alive and see if this “prophecy” played out. And incredibly, a year or so later, it did. Nero committed suicide in June of AD 68. Several Roman senators declared themselves the new emperor. Three of them were killed or committed suicide in quick succession.
Vespasian was fourth to declare himself emperor, and he was powerful enough to make it stick. By the end of the Year of Four Emperors, in AD 69, the Roman Senate acknowledged Vespasian as the new Caesar.
During this turmoil, the war in Judea was put on ice. Once Vespasian had a lock on power, he handed off the Judean war to his oldest son Titus. And our man Yoseph, who had now been “proved” to be a prophet, served as Titus’s interpreter.
So Yoseph was there when Titus captured Jerusalem in the summer of AD 70 and burned the Temple. It’s easy to condemn Yoseph as a coward and a traitor. But without him, we wouldn’t know any of this, because once the war was over, Yoseph went to Rome and lived on a pension provided by the emperor and became…
Josephus, the Author
The name Yoseph is Hebrew. When you transmute it into Latin, it becomes Josephus. Our man Yoseph’s patron Vespasian belonged to the so-called Flavian dynasty, so Yoseph is known to us by his Latin name, Flavius Josephus.
Yoseph lived on for another 20 or 30 years, lasting until near the end of the first century. He wrote a best-selling history called The Jewish War, which he published in Rome about the year AD 79, telling the tale of the war in which he played a part. Then he wrote another very long book of the history of his people (summarizing all the stories of the Hebrew Bible, but also continuing the tale beyond what we know in the Hebrew Bible). He called this book Antiquities of the Jews, and published it around the year AD 93. He included a short “autobiography” which he titled Life of Josephus, and he later wrote a short apologetic work about his religion.
Imagine There’s No Josephus
It’s easy if you try. If Josephus had not survived and written his history books, we’d know much less about Jewish history in the two centuries BC. We’d know very little about Jewish history in the time of Jesus. We would be aware that Rome had destroyed Jerusalem, but we’d know almost nothing about how that came about.
We would have little understanding of the inhabitants of Jerusalem in the first century—the kings and priests and rabbis and prophets and bandits and Roman governors.
We would still have the New Testament, but we would not have much context for understanding its stories.
So it’s fine to say Josephus was a very naughty boy who was a coward and a liar and a con man. There’s some truth to that. But it’s not the whole truth. Josephus was a survivor and a storyteller. He was well-connected to many of the major players in the history of the Jewish War—to Vespasian and Titus and King Agrippa and Queen Berenike and all the chief priests in the city and all the Jewish rebels who launched the insurrection and all the great rabbis who later created rabbinic Judaism. He probably knew James the brother of Jesus. He may have seen the apostle Paul.
When you read the works of Josephus, you need to always keep in mind that he’s not perfectly honest about his enemies and he often brags about his own brilliance. And he sometimes makes mistakes that show his memory was imperfect. But he’s pretty much all we have. And that’s something. I, for one, am glad he survived and told his story. Because it’s a heck of a story.
